Il Mattone

J (J) 2 months ago

I regret we didn't have a great experience here. We ordered a full cheese pizza and a single pineapple slice. The cheese pizza did taste like it had fresh ingredients, but overall was just fairly mid. The pineapple slice wasn't even ready when we got there and their solution is the attached photo: they took a cheese slice and just laid the ham and pineapple on top with no cooking.

Ash N. Smith 4 months ago

Came upon this place by chance after dinner in Tribeca. Omg. 😳 from the first bites of the plain slice I knew I was in a fantastic pizzeria. These guys are the old school nyc style pizzerias that are rapidly harder to find. The slices I tried were delicious. Definitely will come back for their parm sandwiches and their salads. They even had a small tv on showing the nba playoffs! What a gem of a spot!

Erin Howard 4 months ago

Living in downtown Manhattan, we have endless options when it comes to Italian food, but for our Super Bowl party we decided to try Il Mattone for the first time — and wow, were we impressed. We ordered several pies, and every one arrived hot, cheesy, and absolutely delicious. I was thrilled to discover such a fantastic gem right in our area. A few weeks later, I ordered entrees when friends came over, and again the meals were outstanding and very reasonably priced. Last night, my husband and I tried the Chicken Parm and Chicken Marsala. He loved the parm, which secretly made me happy because it meant I didn’t have to share the Marsala! Everything was beautifully cooked and full of flavor. Il Mattone has officially become our go-to spot. Living in a large complex in Battery Park, I’ve been recommending them to everyone — although many people already seem to know how great they are. Looking forward to many more exceptional meals from Il Mattone!

Leila 8 months ago

We’ve been getting food from here for years and it’s always been exceptional. We regularly order the ziti pizza pie along with cheese pies. The ziti pizza pies are always prepared exceptionally so we didn’t open the box to check before we left, as we expected what we usually get. Not only was the food terribly prepared, but when I called to order, a staff member picked up and was yelling something at me and I was unable to understand what he was saying. He then hung up on me. I was informed shortly afterward that it was the OWNER speaking to me like that and that he was “drunk.” Lol. Very unprofessional and disappointing. Won’t be ordering from here anymore. Will spread the word too !!!!!!

Elias Chelala (Chewy) a year ago

The pizza is fantastic—crispy crust, just the right amount of char, and quality ingredients that actually taste fresh. I went with the classic Margherita and a white pie with prosciutto, and both were perfectly balanced and flavorful. The sauce has that rich, tangy depth that shows they take pride in the basics. Atmosphere is casual but cozy, with a laid-back staff that makes you feel right at home. It’s the kind of place where you can relax with friends over a cold beer and a hot pie without feeling rushed. Whether you’re in for a quick slice or a full sit-down meal, Il Mattone delivers. Definitely one of the better pizza joints in the area.